What triggers a §409A violation?

Late elections, handshake deferrals, early payouts, or haircut provisions — any deviation from a written plan meeting the statute. The penalty applies per affected employee and the employer’s plan document gets the blame.

Do stock options face §409A?

Options granted at fair market value with no extra deferral feature are exempt — which is why 409A valuations exist. Discounted options, extended exercise windows, and cash-settled SARs can all fall inside the statute.

Can a §409A failure be fixed?

Sometimes: the IRS correction programs allow rescissions and operational fixes in the same tax year, with limited relief after year-end. Document the error, fix it fast, and attach the required statements — or pay the 20%.

IRC §409A · 26 U.S.C. §409A

IRC §409A: Nonqualified Deferred Compensation

By Paul D. Diaz, EA, MBA · Updated September 20, 2026

IRC §409A polices deferred pay at private companies — strict election timing, fixed distribution triggers, and a 20% penalty plus interest on every violation. Defer wrong and the tax hits years early.

What it governs

Elections generally due the year BEFORE the compensation is earned
Distributions only on six triggers: separation, disability, death, fixed date, change in control, emergency
Violations: immediate taxation plus 20% penalty plus premium interest
Stock options and SARs mostly exempt if priced at fair market value on grant

In the GuideFull treatment in Chapter 21 of the Guide — THE TAX CUTTERY® Guide to Federal Income Taxation, Professional Edition (564 pages, 24 chapters).

From the practiceStart the consultation — Paul on video, one question at a time →

Questions this section answers

What triggers a §409A violation?: Late elections, handshake deferrals, early payouts, or haircut provisions — any deviation from a written plan meeting the statute. The penalty applies per affected employee and the employer’s plan document gets the blame.
Do stock options face §409A?: Options granted at fair market value with no extra deferral feature are exempt — which is why 409A valuations exist. Discounted options, extended exercise windows, and cash-settled SARs can all fall inside the statute.
Can a §409A failure be fixed?: Sometimes: the IRS correction programs allow rescissions and operational fixes in the same tax year, with limited relief after year-end. Document the error, fix it fast, and attach the required statements — or pay the 20%.

The whole Code, one volume.
The Guide treats 149 Code sections across 24 chapters — every claim verified against primary sources.
Get the Guide — $299